Chicago is throwing its ‘whole government’ at summer violence
That’s how Jervon Hicks describes his mission as an outreach worker and life coach on Chicago’s South Side.
Growing up in the city, Hicks, 44, found himself behind bars multiple times for what he says was “guns and shooting.” Now, he’s trying to prevent his history from becoming someone else’s future.
“No amount of money can change what’s going on if you don’t have your feet on the ground,” said Hicks.
It’s a critical part of the city’s wider-ranging approach to help prevent gun violence in Chicago — what Mayor Lori Lightfoot has called a “whole-of-government approach” to public safety.
Through mid-June, the city has recorded more than a 30% increase in murders compared to 2019, and a nearly 60% jump over the same period when it came to shootings, according to data released by the Chicago Police Department.
The new whole-of-government strategy highlights four “zones” across Chicago the city says are driving a disproportionate amount of violent crime. Then, using schools, libraries, family support services and other departments, the city is trying to fight violence with resources, all the way down to the block level.
The strategy was announced in late May based on data from the summers of 2018, 2019 and 2020, Lightfoot announced at a news conference.
“Historically, these 15 areas account for over 50% of the violence in our city. So if we can make a meaningful difference in these areas, we will make a meaningful difference in the entirety of public safety across our whole city,” Lightfoot said at the time.
The city’s increase in violent crime reflects a nationwide trend as gun violence continues to soar leading into the summer months.
“Our young men, the ones that are most likely to be the victims, but also the perpetrators of crime, have to know at the earliest possible stage, their destiny is not pre-ordained to be picking up a gun, minding somebody’s corner spot, going to jail, or an early death,” Lightfoot told CNN.
“Having a strategy that relies exclusively or even primarily just on law enforcement doesn’t work. And we know that. We’ve spent billions of dollars across the city policing without other supports for communities and it’s not moving the needle fast enough, deeply enough or permanently enough,” Lightfoot said.
“Policing has to be different’
Despite a focus on more community support, police are still a major part of the whole-of-government public safety approach, even if it means “shut up and listen.”
“If you’re not, as a law enforcement leader or officer, open to reform, you’re in the wrong business. We have to change our culture. Full stop. Put a period right there. There’s no going back to the way it used to be,” said Chicago Police Superintendent David Brown in an interview with CNN. “Policing has to be different.”
Some have questioned whether “different” should mean less. The Chicago Police Department employs roughly 13,000 police officers, making it the second-largest police department in the country despite being the third-largest city.
“Let’s just say for example, instead of 13,000 police officers we had 8,000, but we had 5,000 more outreach workers, clinicians, life coaches, educators, job developers who are stopping the violence,” said Arne Duncan, co-founder of CRED and a former US secretary of education. “We’ve got to give them a reason to stop committing crimes and put down the guns.”
Brown doesn’t disagree with that notion but said he doesn’t believe the infrastructure is there yet to be as effective as many would hope, especially in certain neighborhoods.
“If they get addicted to drugs, they can’t go to California and be in that really nice swanky addiction treatment facility. They’ve got to go to a facility that’s — the line is out the building. You make an appointment, you get it next month while you deal with your addiction,” said Brown.
“So you’re saying let’s pull back on policing before we have some of these solutions that we envision will work without the capacity or the function,” he said.
The policy is still undergoing input from the community and a federal consent decree independent monitor, but it includes prohibiting foot chases stemming from minor traffic offenses, positioning officers in a way that discourages running, and prohibiting punishment for deciding not to engage in or continue a foot chase.
It’s being implemented in an interim form and expected to take final shape later this year within compliance of a federal consent decree and its Independent Monitoring Team.
“It doesn’t lead to higher crime, it doesn’t prevent officers from doing their jobs, so let’s debunk those myths,” Brown said in an interview with CNN. “It actually makes us safer because officers are safer as it relates to foot pursuit policies and the outcomes for offenders fleeing is safer.”
Nationwide spike in violence
CNN defines a mass shooting as four or more people shot, not including the shooter.
“What changed in 2020 is the pandemic, and we’re still seeing those pandemic effects,” said Lightfoot. “We know how to fight this, but we’ve got to use every tool in our tool box.”
Of Chicago’s 77 neighborhoods, 23 are more than 80% Black and over half of those suffer from “high levels of economic hardship,” according to The State of Health for Blacks in Chicago, a report released by the city’s public health department. All of the “whole-of-government” violence zones feature at least one of those neighborhoods suffering economic hardship — such as Roseland, where Hicks is from.
It’s part of why the city declared racism a public health crisis, hoping to shift toward investigating root causes rather than being responsive.
Through June, Chicago’s homicide rate saw a slight improvement, up only 4% from the same time last year, compared with January when the number of homicides was up 34% at that time compared to January 2020, according to the Chicago Police Department.
Outreach in an ‘extraordinarily dark time’
The stakes are as high as human life, and those working to preserve it aren’t immune.
“It started with the pandemic, and then the George Floyd murder,” said Duncan, CRED’s co-founder. “Those next six or eight weeks after that were honestly probably the worst six or eight weeks of my life. We had a staff member killed, we had three of our young men killed, we had a 20-month-old baby of one our men (that) was killed, and it was just an extraordinarily dark time.”
Just before CNN’s interview with Duncan and Hicks, a 16-year-old who Duncan said was “just starting” to engage with their program was shot and killed.
It’s a reality that adds urgency for outreach workers such as Hicks.
“I done had situations where I know (mediators) have been called and didn’t come out and a few hours later this individual done got locked up or maybe even shot,” said Hicks.
Building from the ground up is the only way to make any meaningful change, said Duncan, who also pushed back on negative stereotypes he says some of his men and women face because of their histories or because of how they look as Black men.
“Many of our staff used to shoot people. You can perceive them some way, (but) they are literally life savers every single day. We can’t win this battle without them,” said Duncan.
“Men who look like that, men who live in these neighborhoods, are giving everything they have. And I don’t want to get emotional saying this — they’re giving everything they have to create peace and to save the next generation. They are the answer,” continued Duncan.
“We care for real, I mean I don’t — I don’t get accolades for this, I don’t make social media posts about things that I done done. It’s not about me,” said Hicks. “If you want to be in the streets, so be it. If you want to change, that’s what we’re here for.”
CNN’s Ray Sanchez and Peter Nickeas contributed to this report.